<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<?xml-model href="http://www.stoa.org/epidoc/schema/latest/tei-epidoc.rng" schematypens="http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0"?>
<?xml-model href="http://www.stoa.org/epidoc/schema/latest/tei-epidoc.rng" schematypens="http://purl.oclc.org/dsdl/schematron"?>
<?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="ashli.xsl" ?>
<TEI xmlns:ashmli="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
    <teiHeader>
        <fileDesc>
            <titleStmt><title>EPITAPH, WITH PROVISIONS AGAINST TOMB VIOLATION (ROME)</title>
            <editor>Alison E. Cooley</editor></titleStmt>
            <publicationStmt>
                <authority>AEC/ASHL</authority>
                <idno type="filename">ANChandler.3.27.xml</idno>
            </publicationStmt>
            <sourceDesc>
                <msDesc>
                    <msIdentifier>
                        <settlement>Oxford</settlement>
                        <repository>Ashmolean Museum</repository>
                        <idno>ANChandler.3.27</idno>
                        <altIdentifier>
                            <idno>AshLI 26</idno>
                        </altIdentifier>
                    </msIdentifier>
                    <physDesc>
                        <objectDesc>
                            <supportDesc>
                                <support>
                                    <p>: A plain <objectType ref="http://www.eagle-network.eu/voc/objtyp/lod/259.html">slab</objectType> of
                                        <material ref="http://www.eagle-network.eu/voc/material/lod/49.html">white marble</material> (in a modern mount) 
                                        (<dimensions><height unit="metre">0.31</height> <width unit="metre">0.59</width> <depth unit="metre">0.044</depth></dimensions>). 
                                        The rear is not visible because of the modern mount. The stone’s front face is not flat (possibly a sign of re-use or of poor workmanship). 
                                        The top of the stone has been cut away, and it is unclear how many lines of text are missing from the start. 
                                        Two broken pieces have been joined together; a further missing piece has been replaced with modern plaster at the top left. 
                                        Doni and Fabretti mistakenly joined this fragmentary inscription up to the end of <ref target="ANChandler.3.24.xml">3-24</ref>, as a result of not working from the 
                                        monuments themselves.</p>
                                </support></supportDesc>
                            <layoutDesc><layout>
                                <p>The text is not <rs type="execution" key="scalpro">engraved</rs> with great care, and the level of literacy shown is also somewhat lacking. EORVM in line 3 seems 
                                    to be a later addition to the text, inserted in between the longer lines and in smaller letters. 
                                    Line 4 lacks the letter T in POST. In line 5, BENDERE HAC DONARE probably stands for the common formula VENDERE AVT DONARE (compare CIL VI 10876, 13074, 18107, 
                                    20989, 22116, 24378, 33900).
                                    In line 6, the stonecutter has added a much smaller letter E on a line of its own in order to correct the word below it, VOLVRIT, to VOLVERIT 
                                    (as on the previous line), and the dative form ARCAE is inscribed as ARCE. The final M in PONTEFICVM is much smaller, squeezed in at the end of the line.
                                    There are simple interpuncts.</p>
                            </layout></layoutDesc>
                        </objectDesc>
                        <handDesc>
                            <handNote><height unit="cm">2.5cm</height> (line 1); <height unit="cm">2.6cm</height> (line 2); <height unit="cm">1.5cm</height> variable (line 3); 
                                <height unit="cm">2.8cm</height> (line 4); <height unit="cm">2.6cm</height> (line 5); <height unit="cm">2.7cm</height> with E of VOLVERIT 
                                <height unit="cm">1.4cm</height> (line 6); <height unit="cm">2.1cm</height> (lines 7-8).</handNote>
                        </handDesc>
                    </physDesc>
                    <history>
                        <origin>
                            <origPlace>It probably originated from <placeName ref="https://pleiades.stoa.org/places/423025">Rome</placeName></origPlace>
                            <origDate notBefore="0150" notAfter="0250">perhaps mid-second to third century AD.</origDate>
                        </origin>
                        <provenance type="observed" when="1667">Of unknown provenance, it probably originated from <placeName ref="https://pleiades.stoa.org/places/423025">Rome</placeName>,
                            given its reference to the treasury of the pontifices.
                            It was first recorded in Oxford by <ref target="#prideaux1676">Prideaux (1676)</ref>, as part of the Arundel Collection, given to the University of Oxford by
                            Henry Howard, Earl of Arundel, in 1667. 
                            The Arundel marbles were first displayed in the ‘Garden of Antiquities’ outside the new Sheldonian Theatre from 1668/9 (<ref target="#sturdy1999">Sturdy and Moorcraft 1999</ref>). 
                            The marbles were subsequently transferred indoors in 1715 to ‘The Marble School’, an upper gallery in the Bodleian quadrangle. In 1749, 
                            they were transferred downstairs to the ground floor in the former School of Moral Philosophy, and at some point then ended up in the basement of the 
                            (Old) Ashmolean Museum on Broad Street (now the Museum of the History of Science) (<ref target="#munby2013">Munby 2013</ref>). The Ashmolean Museum in its 
                            current location was built behind the University Galleries on Beaumont Street, was opened in 1894, and finally the University Galleries and Ashmolean were 
                            amalgamated by statute in 1908. </provenance>
                        <provenance type="autopsy" when="2014">The inscription is currently in store.</provenance>
                    </history>
                </msDesc>
            </sourceDesc>
        </fileDesc>
    </teiHeader>
    <facsimile>
        <surface><graphic url="//latininscriptions.ashmus.ox.ac.uk/images/high/AN_Chandler_3_27.jpg"><desc>Photograph</desc></graphic></surface>
        <surface><graphic url="//latininscriptions.ashmus.ox.ac.uk/images/high/AN_Chandler_3_27_(1).jpg"><desc>Photograph</desc></graphic></surface>
    </facsimile>
    <text>
        <body>
           
            <div type="edition" xml:space="preserve" xml:lang="Latn">
                <ab>
                    <lb n="0"/> <gap reason="lost" quantity="1" unit="line"/>
                    <lb n="1"/> se vivo <supplied reason="lost">si</supplied>bi <g type="interpunct"/> et <g type="interpunct"/> suis <g type="interpunct"/> libertis
                    <lb n="2"/> libertabusque posterisque
                    <lb n="3"/> eorum
                    <lb n="4"/> itaque <g type="interpunct"/> si pos<supplied reason="omitted">t</supplied> obitum <g type="interpunct"/> nostrum
                    <lb n="5"/> voluerit <choice><corr>v</corr><sic>b</sic></choice>endere <choice><corr>aut</corr><sic>hac</sic></choice> donare
                    <lb n="6"/> volu<hi rend="small">e</hi>rit <g type="interpunct"/> inferet <g type="interpunct"/> arc<supplied reason="omitted">a</supplied>e ponteficum
                    <lb n="7"/> <expan><abbr><am><g type="sestertius">U+053 U+0336 U+0053 U+0336</g></am></abbr><ex>sestertium</ex></expan> <num value="100000">centumilia</num> 
                        <g type="interpunct"/> nummum
                    <lb n="8"/> <expan><abbr>h</abbr><ex>oc</ex></expan> <expan><abbr>m</abbr><ex>onumentum</ex></expan> <expan><abbr>h</abbr><ex>eredibus</ex></expan>
                        <expan><abbr>n</abbr><ex>on</ex></expan> <expan><abbr>s</abbr><ex>equetur</ex></expan>
                </ab>
            </div>
            <div type="translation" xml:lang="en">
                <p>…in his lifetime for himself and for his freedmen and freedwomen and for their descendants. 
                    Therefore if after our death anyone shall wish to sell or shall wish to give, he shall pay 100,000 sesterces to the pontifices’ treasury.
                    This monument will not follow the heirs.</p>
            </div>
            <div type="apparatus">
                <listApp>
                    <app loc="1"><note> SE VIVOS SIBI (Sirmond; Doni Lat. Barb. 2756); VIVOS (Fabretti); **BI (Chandler); SIBI (Prideaux; Maittaire)</note></app>
                    <app loc="4"><note> POST OBITVM (Doni MS. cod. Lat. Barb. 2756)</note></app>
                    <app loc="5"><note> BENDERE HAC DONARE (lapis; Doni MS. cod. Barb. Lat.  2756); VENDERE AC DONARE (Sirmond)</note></app>
                    <app loc="6"><note> VOLVERIT INFERET ARCAE PONTIFICVM (Sirmond; Doni BN Naples MS MS G.XII.75 fol.355, no.4); VOLVERIT INFERET ARCE PONTIFICVM 
                        (Doni MS. cod. Barb.  Lat. 2756); PONTIFICVM (Fabretti; Doni BN Naples MS G.XII.75 fol.355, no.4)</note></app>
                    <app loc="9"><note> CENTVMILLIA (Doni BN Naples MS G.XII.75 fol.355, no.4; Doni MS. cod. Barb. Lat. 2756); CENTVM MILIA (Sirmond, Prideaux, Maittaire);
                        CENTV (Maittaire p.562)</note></app>
                </listApp>
            </div> 
            
            <div type="commentary">
                <p>The beginning of the inscription has been lost; its extant part begins with threatening a large fine, to be paid to the pontifices, 
                    in the event of the tomb property being sold at a later date. Such a payment to the treasury of the pontifices suggests a date from the mid-second century or
                    later (<ref target="#mommsen1887">Mommsen 1887-1888</ref>: p.70). The large sum is rather unexpected, perhaps, on an inscription whose quality of carving and 
                    literacy are somewhat questionable. 
                    See also commentary on <ref target="ANChandler.3.18.xml">C3-18</ref>, <ref target="ANChandler.3.39.xml">C3-39</ref> for other concerns about heirs not upkeeping a tomb properly 
                    (HMHNS), and for other threats of fines (overview in <ref target="#gregori2004">Gregori 2004</ref>: pp.391-404). </p>
            </div>
            <div type="bibliography" subtype="Editions">
                <p><ref target="#sirmond">Sirmond MS. BNF Paris suppl. Lat. 1419 = Lat. 10808</ref>, no. 270; 
                    <ref target="#doniVat">Doni MS. cod. Vat. Lat. 7113</ref> f.42’ (added on to end of <ref target="ANChandler.3.24.xml">C3-24</ref>, in error); 
                    <ref target="#doniNaples">Doni BN Naples, MS G.XII.75</ref> fol.355, no.4 (repeats the same error); <ref target="#doniBarb">Doni Lat. Barb. 2756</ref> f.156; 
                    <ref target="#prideaux1676">Prideaux (1676)</ref> p.148, no.115; 
                    <ref target="#fabretti1702">Fabretti (1702)</ref> p.92 no.190 (following Barberini schedae); <ref target="#maittaire1732">Maittaire (1732)</ref> p.40, no.93 + 562;
                    <ref target="#chandler1763">Chandler (1763)</ref> p.133, no.27; CIL VI.4.fasc.1 no. 29925 [Hübner] (1894)</p>
            </div>
            <div type="bibliography" subtype="Scholarship">
                <listBibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="chandler1763">
                        <author><surname>Chandler</surname> <forename>R.</forename></author>
                        <date>1763</date> <title level="m">Marmora Oxoniensia</title>
                        <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace> <publisher>Clarendon Press</publisher> 
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="doniVat">
                        <author><surname>Doni</surname> <forename>Giovanni Battista</forename> [Donius]</author>
                        <date>1594-1647</date> <title level="m">cod. Vat. Lat. 7113</title>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="doniNaples">
                        <author><surname>Doni</surname> <forename>Giovanni Battista</forename> [Donius]</author>
                        <date>1594-1647</date> <title level="m">BN Naples, MS G.XII.75</title>
                        <note>[digital scan]</note>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="doniBarb">
                        <author><surname>Doni</surname> <forename>Giovanni Battista</forename> [Donius]</author>
                        <date>1594-1647</date> <title level="m">MS. cod. Barb. Lat. 2756</title>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="fabretti1702">
                        <author><forename>Fabretti</forename> <surname>R.</surname></author>
                        <date>1702</date> <title level="m">Inscriptionum antiquarum quae in aedibus paternis asseruantur explicatio et additamentum</title>
                        <pubPlace>Rome</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="gregori2004">
                        <author><surname>Gregori</surname><forename>G.L.</forename></author>
                        <date>2004</date> <title level="a">Si quis contra legem sepulcri fecerit. Violazioni e pene pecuniarie</title>
                        <title level="m">Libitina e dintorni. Libitina e i luci sepolcrali. Le leges libitinarie campane. Iura sepulcrorum: vecchie e nuove iscrizioni</title>
                        <pubPlace>Rome</pubPlace> <publisher>Libitina 3/ Quasar</publisher> 
                        <biblScope unit="391-404"></biblScope>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="maittaire1732">
                        <author><surname>Maittaire</surname> <forename>M.</forename></author>
                        <date>1732, 2nd edn.</date> <title level="m">Marmorum, Arundellianorum, Seldenianorum, Aliorumque Academiae Oxoniensi Donatorum</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace> <publisher>William Bowyer</publisher>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="mommsen1887">
                        <author><surname>Mommsen</surname><forename>T.</forename></author>
                        <date>1887-1888, 3rd edn</date>
                        <title level="m">Römisches Staatsrecht</title>
                        <pubPlace>Leipzig</pubPlace> <publisher>S. Herzel</publisher>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="prideaux1676">
                        <author><surname>Prideaux</surname> <forename>H.</forename></author>
                        <date>1676</date> <title level="m">Marmora Oxoniensia ex Arundellianis, Seldenianis, aliisque conflata</title>
                        <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace> 
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="sirmond">
                        <author><surname>Sirmond</surname> <forename>J.</forename> [Sirmondus]</author>
                    <date>1559-1651</date>
                        <title level="m">Recueil d'inscriptions copiées par Sirmond. Bibliothèque nationale de France, Département des manuscrits, Paris suppl. Lat. 1419 =  Lat. 10808</title>
                        <note>[consulted online 10/06/14 at http://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b9077728w]</note>
                    <bibl xml:base="sturdy1999">
                        <author><surname>Sturdy</surname> <forename>D.</forename></author> and <author><forename>N.</forename> <surname>Moorcraft</surname></author>
                        <date>1999</date> <title level="a">Christopher Wren and Oxford’s garden of antiquities</title>
                        <title level="j">Minvera</title> <biblScope unit="vol">10.1</biblScope>
                        <biblScope unit="page">25-28.</biblScope></bibl>
                    </bibl>
                </listBibl>
            </div>
        </body>
    </text>
</TEI>
