<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<?xml-model href="http://www.stoa.org/epidoc/schema/latest/tei-epidoc.rng" schematypens="http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0"?>
<?xml-model href="http://www.stoa.org/epidoc/schema/latest/tei-epidoc.rng" schematypens="http://purl.oclc.org/dsdl/schematron"?>
<?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="ashli.xsl" ?>
<TEI xmlns:ashmli="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
    <teiHeader>
        <fileDesc>
            <titleStmt><title>A SOLDIER'S EPITAPH, LONDON</title>
            <editor>Alison E. Cooley</editor></titleStmt>
            <publicationStmt>
                <authority>AEC/ASHL</authority>
                <idno type="filename">ANChandler.3.10.xml</idno>
                <idno type="TM">154510</idno>
            </publicationStmt>
            <sourceDesc>
                <msDesc>
                    <msIdentifier>
                        <settlement>London</settlement>
                        <repository>Museum of London</repository>
                        <idno>ANChandler.3.10</idno>
                        <altIdentifier>
                            <idno>AshLI 09</idno>
                        </altIdentifier>
                    </msIdentifier>
                    <physDesc>
                        <objectDesc>
                            <supportDesc>
                                <support>
                                    <p>A <objectType ref="http://www.eagle-network.eu/voc/objtyp/lod/250.html">stele</objectType> of 
                                        <material ref="http://www.eagle-network.eu/voc/material/lod/66.html">limestone</material>, with an inscription at the top, and a 
                                        <rs type="decoration">full-length male figure</rs> in a niche below (<dimensions><height unit="metre">2.09</height> <width unit="metre">0.78</width> 
                                         <depth unit="metre">0.27</depth></dimensions>). 
                                        The rear remains rough and unfinished. The figure carved in the niche is roughly three-quarters lifesized 
                                        (<dimensions><height unit="metre">1.23</height></dimensions> tall/ roughly 4 feet). 
                                        He stands facing the viewer, and is represented with short tunic, belt, and cloak, carrying a staff in his right hand, and what appears to be a scroll in his left. 
                                        The wooden staff might be taken as a mark of status as a centurion. 
                                        His face has worn away. Some illustrations of the tombstone have restored the figure in various ways, representing him with short hair 
                                        (<ref target="#gale1709">Gale 1709</ref>) or with ringlets (<ref target="#horsley1732">Horsley 1732</ref>) according to contemporary fashion, 
                                        and depicting him as bearing a sword. The unreliability of such illustrations (cf. also <ref target="#allen1827">Allen 1827</ref>: pp.20-21) is noted by 
                                        <ref target="#knight1841">Knight</ref> (1841: p.286), who critiques the desire (e.g. by <ref target="#pennant1790">Pennant 1790</ref>: pp.11-12) to identify 
                                        Marcianus as a ‘British-born’ soldier, 
                                        precisely on the basis of such inaccurate drawings. A much more reliable image, executed in watercolour over graphite, was produced by J.W. Archer in 1852 
                                        (now in the British Museum: BM inv. 1874,0314.234; and accessible online as image AN651893001). 
                                        There are two secondary dowel-holes in line 3 of the inscription, another in the figure’s chest, and another half way up on the right-hand edge of the monument 
                                        (with remains of metal still visible). 
                                        The former apparently caused some confusion in early accounts of the text (see below). There is also a small rectangular dowel hole on both left and right side 
                                        edges, corresponding to each other, at about the neck height of the figure. 
                                        The bottom right edge of the tombstone is slightly cut away, up to the height of the figure’s knee. The surface of the inscription is eroded and scratched.</p>
                                </support></supportDesc>
                            <layoutDesc><layout>
                                <p>Horizontal lines across the width of the stone, below the first line and above the last line, mark out an <rs type="execution" key="scalpro">inscribed</rs> area. 
                                    Inscribed area: <dimensions><height unit="metre">0.54</height></dimensions>.</p>
                            </layout></layoutDesc>
                        </objectDesc>
                        <handDesc>
                            <handNote><height unit="metre">0.052</height> (line 1); <height unit="metre">0.06 + 0.035</height> (line 2); <height unit="metre">0.053</height> (line 3); 
                                <height unit="metre">0.05 </height> (line 4); <height unit="metre">0.046 + 0.024</height> (line 5); <height unit="metre">0.045</height> (line 6); 
                                <height unit="metre">0.048</height> (line 7). 
                                In line 2, the final I is smaller, wrapped within the C. 
                                In addition to fairly large triangular interpuncts (throughout, except at line ends), there is an ivy-leaf interpunct in line 3, between ANO and LEG. 
                                <ref target="#wilson1970">Wilson and Wright</ref> (1970: p.315, ‘corrigendum’), 
                                following <ref target="#birley1966">Birley</ref> (1966: p.228), suggest that a centurial sign > may be squeezed in before the ivy-leaf interpunct. 
                                It looks, however, as if either only the top part of this sign is inscribed or its lower part has been worn away. 
                                This mark might otherwise be interpreted as an interpunct, but given that the interpuncts elsewhere in the text are simple triangular marks, 
                                interpreting this mark as the top half of > seems more attractive. 
                                In line 3, O is carved at a higher level than the rest of the letters in that line. 
                                The numeral II in line 3 has a horizontal line across its top. The letters in line 4 are irregularly cut, 
                                deviating from a straight line so as to arch up towards a peak at N. In line 5, the O of CONIVNX is smaller, wrapped inside the C. 
                                There are ligatures in line 5, TI; line 7, RI. In the last line, the word MEMORIAM is split in two, ME…MORIAM, by the rounded top of the niche below.</handNote>
                        </handDesc>
                    </physDesc>
                    <history>
                        <origin>
                            <origPlace>St Martin’s Church, Ludgate Hill, <placeName ref="https://pleiades.stoa.org/places/79574">London</placeName></origPlace>
                            <origDate notBefore="0200" notAfter="0299" cert="high">perhaps 3rd century AD (from military context)</origDate>
                        </origin>
                        <provenance type="found" when="1669"> The tombstone was found by Sir Christopher Wren in 1669, when St Martin’s Church, Ludgate Hill, London was being rebuilt 
                            following the Great Fire of 1666. </provenance>
                        <provenance type="observed" notAfter="1676">According to <ref target="#prideaux1676">Prideaux (1676)</ref>, it was brought to Oxford at the expense of the 
                            Archbishop of Canterbury. At the time, this was none other than Gilbert Sheldon (Spurr 2008), who had longstanding ties to the University as Fellow and 
                            Warden of All Souls, Pro-Vice Chancellor and Chancellor, and benefactor of the Sheldonian Theatre, designed by Sir Christopher Wren and completed also in 1669. </provenance>
                        <provenance type="observed" when="1715">The tombstone was consequently displayed in the Garden of Antiquities next to the Sheldonian Theatre 
                            (<ref target="#sturdy1999">Sturdy and Moorcraft 1999</ref>: p.28), before being transferred indoors in 1715 to ‘The Marble School’, an upper gallery in the 
                            Bodleian Quadrangle. 
                            In <date>1749</date>, the collection of marbles was transferred downstairs to the ground floor in the former School of Moral Philosophy, and at some point then
                            ended up in the basement of the (Old) Ashmolean Museum on Broad Street (now the Museum of the History of Science) (<ref target="#munby2013">Munby 2013</ref>). </provenance>
                        <provenance type="observed" when="1931">)In 1931 it was on display in The Arundel Vestibule on the Ground Floor of the museum (<ref target="#leeds1931">Leeds 1931: p.21</ref>).</provenance>
                        <provenance type="autopsy" when="2014">The monument is now on display in the Museum of London. </provenance>
                    </history>
                </msDesc>
            </sourceDesc>
        </fileDesc>
    </teiHeader>
    <facsimile>
        <surface><graphic url="//latininscriptions.ashmus.ox.ac.uk/images/high/AN_Chandler_3_10.jpg"><desc>Photograph: front face</desc></graphic></surface>
        <surface><graphic url="http://romegreeceart.tumblr.com/image/81977807747"><desc>Photograph (Clio Ancient Art and Antiquities, Roman and Greek Art tumblr)</desc></graphic></surface>
    </facsimile>
    <text>
        <body>
           
            <div type="edition" xml:space="preserve" xml:lang="Latn">
                <ab>
                    <lb n="1"/><expan><abbr>d</abbr><ex>is</ex></expan> <expan><abbr>m</abbr><ex>anibus</ex></expan> 
                    <lb n="2"/><persName nymRef="#Vivius"><name type="gentilicium">Vivio</name> <g type="interpunct"/> <name type="cognomen">Marci
                    <lb n="3" break="no"/>ano</name></persName> <choice><unclear><g type="centurioni">U+1019B</g></unclear><unclear><g type="leaf"/></unclear></choice> 
                        <expan><abbr>leg</abbr><ex>ionis</ex></expan> <g type="interpunct"/> <hi rend="supraline"><num value="2">II</num></hi>
                    <lb n="4"/><expan><abbr>Aug</abbr><ex>ustae</ex></expan> <g type="interpunct"/> <persName nymRef="#Ianuaria"><name type="gentilicium">Ianuaria</name>
                    <lb n="5"/><name type="cognomen">Mar<hi rend="ligature">ti</hi>na</name></persName> <g type="interpunct"/> <w lemma="coniunx">coniunx</w>
                    <lb n="6"/> pientissima <g type="interpunct"/> posu
                    <lb n="7" break="no"/>it <g type="interpunct"/> memo<hi rend="ligature">ri</hi>am
                </ab>
            </div>
            <div type="translation" xml:lang="en">
                <p>To the spirits of the departed. Ianuaria Martina, most dutiful wife, set up the monument for Vivius Marcianus, centurion of the 2nd Legion Augusta.</p>
            </div>
            <div type="apparatus">
            <listApp>
                <app loc="1">
                    <note> Omitted (Horsley)</note>
                </app>
                <app loc="3">
                    <note> LEG H (Prideaux); <hi rend="ligature">MI</hi>L. LEG, with ligatured MI (Gale); <hi rend="ligature">MIL</hi>EG, with ligatured MIL (Horsley); 
                        MIL. EG. II (Chandler; Gough fig.); <hi rend="ligature">MIL</hi> <hi rend="ligature">LEG</hi> II, with ligatured MIL and LEG (Gough text; Hübner in CIL);
                        7. LEG.II (Muratori); M LEG. II (Roach Smith);
                        <hi rend="italic">ivy-leaf</hi> LEG II (Collingwood); <hi rend="italic">centurial sign</hi> squeezed in before ivy-leaf (Wilson and Wright)</note>
                </app>
                <app loc="5">
                    <note> MARINA (Prideaux; Muratori); MA<hi rend="ligature">TR</hi>INA, with ligatured TR (Gale; Chandler; Horsley; Roach Smith); MA<hi rend="ligature">RT</hi>INA,
                        with ligatured RT (Hübner in CIL);
                        MAR<hi rend="ligature">TI</hi>NA, with ligatured TI (Collingwood)</note>
                </app>
                <app loc="6">
                    <note> POSVI/T (Prideaux; Maittaire)</note>
                </app>
            </listApp>
            </div>
            <div type="commentary">
                <p>This is a sizeable tombstone set up for a Roman soldier by his wife. The name Vivius is a variant spelling of Vibius, substituting B with V. 
                    There is some dispute about whether or not the inscription does specify his rank, but the depiction of him holding a vine-staff 
                    (<foreign xml:lang="Latn">vitis</foreign>) supports the hypothesis that he was a centurion. 
                    The 2nd Legion Augusta came to Britain during the Claudian invasion and remained until the Romans withdrew from the province, being based at Caerleon by the
                    mid-second century. It was quite usual for individual soldiers to be posted to serve in the provincial capital at London, however. 
                    His presence in London may therefore be explained by supposing him to have been seconded to the staff of the provincial governor there. 
                    The stone dates perhaps to the 3rd century AD. If Martina’s title as ‘wife’ was a legal statement of their relationship, then the tomb would have to date after 
                    <date>AD 197</date>, when soldiers were given the right to marry (<ref target="#merrifield1983">Merrifield 1983</ref>: p.176). 
                    If, however, Vivius Marcianus was a centurion, then, as an officer, he would have been free to marry in any case before that time (<ref target="#birley1966">Birley 1966</ref>: p.228).</p>
            </div>
            <div type="bibliography" subtype="Editions">
                <p><ref target="#prideaux1676">Prideaux (1676)</ref> p.280, no.147, with drawing; <ref target="#gale1709">Gale (1709)</ref> pp.67-68 with fig.; 
                    <ref target="#maittaire1732">Maittaire (1732)</ref> p.46, no.140 (picture); <ref target="#horsley1732">Horsley (1732)</ref> p.331 + Middlesex pl.no.I; 
                    <ref target="#muratori1740">Muratori (1740)</ref> p.871 no.1; <ref target="#chandler1763">Chandler (1763)</ref> Part 3, Pl. II.x, with drawing; 
                    <ref target="#gough1789">Gough (1789)</ref> I pl.xvii fig. 13, II p.16; <ref target="#roachsmith1848">Roach Smith (1848)</ref> p.127, with fig.; 
                    <ref target="#roachsmith1859">Roach Smith (1859)</ref> pp.22-23, with fig.; CIL VII no.23 (Hübner, 1873);
                    <ref target="#taylor1927">Taylor and Collingwood (1927)</ref> p.218 no.38.; <ref target="#collingwood1928">Collingwood (1928)</ref> p.173 no.15 fig. 76, pl. 60;
                    RIB I no.17 (1965); <ref target="#wilson1970">Wilson and Wright (1970)</ref> p.315; RIB I2 no.17 (1995); <ref target="#wacher1995">Wacher (1995)</ref> p.85 + fig.36; 
                    <ref target="#maxfield2006">Maxfield and Dobson (2006)</ref> no.184</p>
                <p>Online: EDCS-07800242 [accessed 10/06/14]; 
                    Online CIL schedae: <ref target="http://cil.bbaw.de/dateien/cil_view.php?KO=KO0087914">http://cil.bbaw.de/dateien/cil_view.php?KO=KO0087914</ref> [accessed 10/06/14]</p>
            </div>
            <div type="bibliography" subtype="Scholarship">
                <listBibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="allen1827">
                        <author><surname>Allen</surname><forename>T.</forename></author>
                        <date>1827</date> <title level="m">History and Antiquities of London, Westminster, Southwark and parts adjacent</title>
                        <biblScope unit="vol">1</biblScope>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="birley1966">
                        <author><surname>Birley</surname><forename>E.</forename></author>
                        <date>1966</date> <title level="a">Review of The Roman Inscriptions of Britain I: Inscriptions on Stone by R. G. Collingwood; R. P. Wright</title>
                        <title level="j">Journal of Roman Studies</title>
                        <biblScope unit="vol">56</biblScope>
                        <biblScope unit="page">226-31</biblScope>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="chandler1763">
                        <author><surname>Chandler</surname><forename>R.</forename></author>
                        <date>1763</date> <title level="m">Marmora Oxoniensia</title>
                        <publisher>Clarendon Press</publisher> <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="collingwood1928">
                        <author><surname>Collingwood</surname><forename>R.G.</forename></author>
                        <date>1928</date> <title level="a">Appendix II. Inscriptions of Roman London</title>
                        <title level="m">Royal Commission on Historical Monuments London</title>
                        <biblScope unit="vol">iii Roman London</biblScope>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="collingwood1965">
                        <author><surname>Collingwood</surname><forename>R.G.</forename></author>
                        <author><surname>Wright</surname><forename>R.P.</forename></author>
                        <date>1965</date> <title level="m">The Roman Inscriptions of Britain.Vol. 1.
                            Inscriptions on Stone [RIB I]</title>
                        <biblScope unit="vol">1</biblScope>
                        <publisher>Clarendon Press</publisher> <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="collingwood1995">
                        <author><surname>Collingwood</surname><forename>R.G.</forename></author>
                        <author><surname>Wright</surname><forename>R.P.</forename></author>
                        with Addenda and Corrigenda by <editor><surname>Tomlin</surname><forename>R.S.O</forename></editor>
                        <date>1995</date>
                        <title level="m">The Roman Inscriptions of Britain. Vol. 1. Inscriptions on Stone [RIB I2]</title>
                        <publisher>Alan Sutton</publisher> <pubPlace>Stroud</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="gale1709">
                        <author><surname>Gale</surname><forename>T.</forename></author>
                        <date>1709</date> <title level="m">Antonini Iter Britanniarum</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="gough1789">
                        <author><surname>Gough</surname><forename>R.</forename></author>
                        <date>1768</date> <title level="m">Britannia by William Camden (translated and enlarged edn)</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="horsley1732">
                        <author><surname>Horsley</surname><forename>J.</forename></author>
                        <date>1732</date> <title level="m">Britannia Romana: or the Roman Antiquities of Britain</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="knight1841">
                        <author><surname>Knight</surname><forename>C.</forename></author>
                        <date>1841</date> <title level="m">London</title>
                        <biblScope unit="vol">2</biblScope>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace> <publisher>Charles Knight &amp; Co.</publisher>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="leeds1931">
                        <author><surname>Leeds</surname><forename>E.T.</forename></author>
                        <date>1931, 4th edn.</date> <title level="m">Ashmolean Museum. Summary Guide, Department of Antiquities</title>
                        <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace> <publisher>Ashmolean Museum</publisher>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="maittaire1732">
                        <author><surname>Maittaire</surname><forename>M.</forename></author>
                        <date>1732, 2nd edn.</date> <title level="m">Marmorum, Arundellianorum, Seldenianorum, Aliorumque Academiae Oxoniensi Donatorum</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace> <publisher>William Bowyer</publisher>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="maxfield2006">
                        <author><surname>Maxfield</surname><forename>V.A.</forename></author> and <author><forename>B.</forename><surname>Dobson</surname></author>
                        <date>2006, 4th edn</date> <title level="m">Inscriptions of Roman Britain</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace> <publisher>LACTOR no.4</publisher>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="merrifield1983">
                        <author><surname>Merrifield</surname><forename>R.</forename></author>
                        <date>1983</date> <title level="m">London. City of the Romans</title>
                        <pubPlace>Berkeley and Los Angeles</pubPlace> <publisher>University of California Press</publisher>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="munby2013">
                        <author><surname>Munby</surname><forename>J.</forename></author>
                        <date>2013</date> <title level="a">A rare collection: Oxford museums past and present</title>
                        <title level="m">Excalibur: Essays on Antiquity and the History of Collecting in Honour of Arthur MacGregor</title>
                        <editor><forename>H.</forename><surname>Wiegel</surname></editor> and <editor><forename>M.</forename><surname>Vickers</surname></editor>
                        <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace> <publisher>BAR Int. ser. 2512</publisher>
                        <biblScope unit="page">75-85</biblScope>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="muratori1740">
                        <author><surname>Muratori</surname><forename>L.A.</forename></author>
                        <date>1740</date> <title level="m">Novus thesaurus veterum inscriptionum</title>
                        <biblScope unit="vol">II</biblScope>
                        <pubPlace>Milan</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="pennant1790">
                        <author><surname>Pennant</surname><forename>T.</forename></author>
                        <date>1790</date> <title level="m">Of London</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="prideaux1676">
                        <author><surname>Prideaux</surname><forename>H.</forename></author>
                        <date>1676</date> <title level="m">Marmora Oxoniensia ex Arundellianis, Seldenianis aliisque conflata</title>
                        <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="roachsmith1848">
                        <author><surname>Roach Smith</surname><forename>C.</forename></author>
                        <date>1848</date> <title level="a">Description of a Roman monument discovered in Play-house Yard, Blackfriars, (Letter from W. Chaffers)</title>
                        <title level="j"> Collectanea Antiqua</title>
                        <biblScope unit="vol">I</biblScope>
                        <biblScope unit="page">125-44</biblScope>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="roachsmith1859">
                        <author><surname>Roach Smith</surname><forename>C.</forename></author>
                        <date>1859</date> <title level="m">Illustrations of Roman London</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="spurr2008">
                        <author><surname>Spurr</surname><forename>J</forename></author>
                        <date>2008</date> <title level="a">Sheldon, Gilbert (1598–1677)</title>
                        <title level="m">Oxford Dictionary of National Biography</title>
                        <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace> <publisher>Oxford University Press, 2004; online edn, May 2008</publisher>
                        <ref target="http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/25304">http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/25304</ref> [accessed 3/3/2014]
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="sturdy1999">
                        <author><surname>Sturdy</surname><forename>D.</forename></author> and <author><forename>N.</forename><surname>Moorcraft</surname></author>
                        <date>1999</date> <title level="a">Christopher Wren and Oxford’s garden of antiquities</title>
                        <title level="j">Minerva</title>
                        <biblScope unit="vol">10.1</biblScope>
                        <biblScope unit="page">25-28</biblScope>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="taylor1927">
                        <author><surname>Taylor</surname><forename>M.V.</forename></author>and <author><surname>Collingwood</surname><forename>R.G.</forename></author>
                        <date>1927</date> <title level="a">Roman Britain in 1927</title>
                        <title level="j">Journal of Roman Studies</title> 
                        <biblScope unit="vol">17</biblScope> 
                        <biblScope unit="page">182-219</biblScope> 
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="wacher1995">
                        <author><surname>Wacher</surname><forename>J.</forename></author> 
                        <date>1995 (2nd edn)</date> <title level="m">The Towns of Roman Britain</title>
                        <pubPlace>London</pubPlace> <publisher>Batsford</publisher>
                    </bibl>
                    <bibl xml:id="wilson1970">
                        <author><surname>Wilson</surname><forename>D.R.</forename></author> <author><surname>Wright</surname><forename>R.P.</forename></author>
                        <date>1970</date> <title level="a">Roman Britain in 1969</title>
                        <title level="j">Britannia</title>
                        <biblScope unit="volume">1</biblScope> <biblScope unit="page">268-315</biblScope>
                    </bibl>
                </listBibl>
            </div>
        </body>
    </text>
</TEI>
